The Core Decision: Lace-Up or Slip-On?
When you're choosing between men's loafers and derby shoes, the first question is practical: do you want a slip-on that's ready in seconds, or a lace-up that lets you adjust the fit throughout the day? Both styles work for casual and smart-casual outfits, but they feel different on your feet and project a different vibe.
The Beaumont Loafers use true moccasin construction, with every needle hole punched and every apron stitch done by hand. That translates to a flexible, foot-contouring fit that molds as you wear them. The Clement Derby, on the other hand, is a lace-up with a bold, grippy wave-patterned sole and double welt detailing—a more structured shoe that gives you a secure, adjustable fit.
Fit and Feel: Moccasin Flexibility vs. Derby Structure
The biggest difference between these two men's casual shoes is how they wrap your foot.
- Beaumont Loafers: Moccasin construction means the leather wraps around your foot with minimal internal structure. The result is a graceful profile that contours your feet, making it a great choice if you prefer a snug, glove-like feel without laces.
- Clement Derby: A derby's open lacing system lets you adjust the tightness across the instep. Combined with a grippy wave-patterned sole, it's a more secure, grounded option for days when you're on your feet a lot.
What the Construction Tells Us
- Beaumont Loafers - Men's: Created with true moccasin construction, every needle hole is punched, and every stitch on the apron is executed by the hand of a master. This handcrafted construction is what gives the Beaumont its flexible, foot-contouring fit—a key advantage for slip-on comfort.

Beaumont Loafers - Men's - Clement Derby - Men’s Water Repellent Suede: This elevated take on the traditional men's derby features a bold, grippy wave-patterned sole and double welt detailing. The grippy sole and double welt add structure and traction, making the Clement a sturdy choice for casual wear in varied conditions.

Clement Derby - Men’s Water Repellent Suede
Style Versatility: From Jeans to Suits
Both shoes are versatile, but they lean in slightly different directions. The Beaumont Loafers are described as sitting comfortably under tailored suits while remaining relaxed enough to pair with chinos, jeans, and trousers. That makes them a true crossover shoe for office-to-weekend transitions.
The Clement Derby, with its water-repellent suede and bold sole, has a more rugged, contemporary character. It shines in casual settings—think dark jeans, chinos, or even unstructured blazers. The water-repellent suede adds practicality for light rain, though it's not a substitute for a fully waterproof boot.
Materials and Sustainability
- Clement Derby - Men’s Water Repellent Suede: This product is made from luxurious suede sourced from a Gold-Rated tannery based in Arzignano, Italy. If sustainable sourcing matters to you, the Clement's Gold-rated tannery (the highest Leather Working Group recognition) is a strong point.
- Beaumont Loafers - Men's: This product is made from full-grain calfskin leather sourced from a Gold-Rated tannery based in Arzignano, Italy. Full-grain calfskin is durable and develops a rich patina over time, making the Beaumont a long-term investment in your wardrobe.
Care Considerations
Suede and calfskin need different care. For the Clement's water-repellent suede, you'll want a suede brush and a protector spray to maintain the nap and water resistance. For the Beaumont's full-grain calfskin, regular polishing and conditioning will keep the leather supple and help it age gracefully.
Neither shoe is designed for heavy outdoor use—they're casual leather shoes meant for urban settings. If you expect to wear them in wet conditions often, the water-repellent suede of the Clement is the more practical choice, but it's still not a waterproof guarantee.
Size and Fit Notes
Both shoes are available in sizes 7 through 14. Because loafers have no laces, getting the size right is especially important—a slip-on that's too loose will cause heel slip, and one that's too tight can be uncomfortable. Derby shoes offer a bit more forgiveness thanks to the lace adjustment.
If you're between sizes, consider how you plan to wear them: with thinner socks for loafers, or with slightly thicker socks for derbies in cooler weather. The supplied information doesn't specify a half-size recommendation, so if you're unsure, ordering your usual size and checking the fit is a reasonable starting point.
Key Trade-Offs at a Glance
Here's a quick summary of what each shoe offers.
- Beaumont Loafers: Pros: Flexible moccasin fit, elegant profile, works with suits and casual wear. Cons: No laces to adjust fit; full-grain calfskin requires regular care.
- Clement Derby: Pros: Adjustable lace-up fit, grippy sole, water-repellent suede for light rain. Cons: More casual look; suede needs protective care.
Which Should You Choose?
Choose the Beaumont Loafers if you want a shoe that moves from the office to dinner without a second thought. Its hand-stitched moccasin construction gives it a distinctive feel that's hard to replicate.
Choose the Clement Derby if you prefer a lace-up with a secure fit and a slightly more rugged, contemporary edge. The water-repellent suede and grippy sole make it a dependable companion for casual days when the weather might turn.
Both are quality men's casual leather shoes from Beckett Simonon, handcrafted with materials from Gold-Rated tanneries. Your choice comes down to whether you value slip-on convenience and elegance or adjustable support and weather-ready suede.


