Two leather shoes, two different jobs
The Tessa Derby and Gemma Pump are both women's leather shoes from the same catalog, but they solve different wardrobe problems. The Tessa is a water-repellent suede derby with a chunky sole, built for durability and a bolder casual-to-polished look. The Gemma is a full-grain leather pump with a calibrated heel, designed to elevate business and dressy outfits. Neither is a universal replacement for the other, so the right pick depends on where you need the shoe to work and how much fit information you can verify before buying.
What the catalog confirms about the Tessa Derby
- Tessa Derby - Water-Repellent Suede - Women's: Water-repellent suede upper sourced from a Gold Rated tannery in Arzignano, Italy. Water-repellent suede gives the Tessa an edge in damp, unpredictable weather without the care demands of untreated suede.

Tessa Derby - Water-Repellent Suede - Women's - Tessa Derby - Water-Repellent Suede - Women's: Signature chunky sole described as secure and grippy, adding height and depth. A grippy, height-adding sole makes the Tessa a practical choice for long days on varied surfaces, not just a style statement.
- Tessa Derby - Water-Repellent Suede - Women's: Handcrafted using traditional methods and lasting materials. Traditional construction signals a shoe built to hold up with care, which matters if you want one pair to span seasons.
- Tessa Derby - Water-Repellent Suede - Women's: Available in Black and Chocolate, sizes 6–11 (with some size gaps in Chocolate). Two neutral colorways and a broad size run make the Tessa easier to fit across different foot sizes, though Chocolate availability is narrower.
What the catalog confirms about the Gemma Pump
- Gemma Pump - Full Grain Leather - Women's: Full-grain calfskin leather from a Gold Rated Italian tannery. Full-grain leather is the strongest part of the hide, so the Gemma is built for a polished look that can handle regular dress wear.

Gemma Pump - Full Grain Leather - Women's - Gemma Pump - Full Grain Leather - Women's: Heel calibrated to give height while working with the overall structure for all-day balance and support. This tells you the heel is not just aesthetic—the design intends the pump to remain wearable through a full workday.
- Gemma Pump - Full Grain Leather - Women's: Pristine silhouette described as highly adaptable for business outfits, sleek skirts, tailored pants, or flared jeans. The Gemma's styling range leans dressy and polished, making it a better match for office and evening looks than rugged casual wear.
- Gemma Pump - Full Grain Leather - Women's: Available in Black and Dove, sizes 6–11 (with some size gaps in Dove). A similar size range to the Tessa means the main fit question is shape and heel preference, not availability.
Tessa Derby vs Gemma Pump at a glance
Use this side-by-side to match each shoe to your actual week. The catalog does not list heel height, exact weight, or break-in time for either shoe, so those details are not confirmed here.
- Upper material: Tessa: water-repellent suede. Gemma: full-grain calfskin leather.
- Sole and heel: Tessa: signature chunky sole described as secure and grippy. Gemma: calibrated heel for height with balance and support.
- Intended look: Tessa: statement derby that moves between casual and polished. Gemma: pristine pump for business and dressy outfits.
- Weather readiness: Tessa: water-repellent suede. Gemma: full-grain leather; water resistance is not confirmed in the supplied record.
- Size range: Both list sizes 6–11, with narrower color availability in some sizes (Chocolate for Tessa, Dove for Gemma).
- Care guidance: Neither product record includes specific cleaning or conditioning instructions. Follow general suede care for the Tessa and leather care for the Gemma, and test any product on a small area first.
Fit and sizing: what you can and cannot confirm
Both shoes list sizes 6 through 11, but the catalog does not state whether they run true to size, narrow, or wide. That means your best starting point is your usual women's size, followed by a careful review of the store's fit notes or exchange policy before ordering. The Gemma's pump shape and heel may feel different from the Tessa's derby silhouette even in the same listed size, so do not assume a shared fit. If you are between sizes or have a wider foot, the absence of width options in the supplied records is a real limitation to weigh.
Which shoe fits your week?
- Choose the Tessa Derby if: You want a water-repellent suede shoe for damp commutes, casual Fridays, and outfits that benefit from a chunky sole and a bit of height. It is the more weather-ready and visually bold option.
- Choose the Gemma Pump if: You need a polished full-grain leather pump for business meetings, dresses, and tailored looks, and you prefer a heel calibrated for all-day balance over a flat or chunky sole.
- Consider both if: Your wardrobe spans rugged casual and dressy professional settings. They cover different ground, and neither is confirmed as a substitute for the other's specific strengths.
Care and wear: what the records do not answer
The supplied product records do not include step-by-step care instructions, break-in times, or waterproofing guarantees for either shoe. The Tessa's suede is water-repellent, but that is not the same as waterproof, and the Gemma's full-grain leather is not described as water-resistant. For the Tessa, use a suede brush and protector according to the product care guidance that comes with the shoe. For the Gemma, follow standard full-grain leather care. If you need exact cleaning steps, check the care card included with your order or contact the store rather than guessing.


